Afmob wrote:
I decided to make a messy Assassin since it's been a long time since Messy One #6.
The cage pattern was certainly a good Messy One but this Assassin was waaaay harder than any in the Messy One series, even though the SS score is fairly low.
Ronnie G wrote:
... and it took me a good 2 hours, maybe a little longer, to solve. I'm getting slow in my old age!
IMHO that's quick for solving an Assassin. This one took me a lot longer; I got stuck and came back to it later. I did manage to solve A156, including writing my walkthrough as I went along, in that sort of time but the only other Assassins that I can remember solving in that time were Ruud's very early ones when I was writing walkthroughs but not posting them.
I get the impression that Afmob is a much quicker solver than I am. I don't know how long others take.
manu wrote:
My first solving path was using some contradictions between combos which was not satisfying, until I found step 2a of my WT ( two cloned cages).
So did I; see step 14 of my first walkthrough.
manu wrote:
This is a hard to solve puzzle that resists a lot, until the end !
It certainly does!
manu's step 2a is really neat! The immediate result in step 2b was obtained more directly by Ronnie's step 7 and my step 11. However its importance became obvious with manu's steps 2d and 2e. These led more quickly to the first placement and to a shorter WT.
Congratulations Ronnie on your first posted WT! An excellent effort!
After mentioning to Ed that I'd used difficult combination analysis (step 14) and an ALS block (step 16) he told me that I must have missed something easy. I therefore went back and eventually found what I'd missed. As a result I've decided to post both my walkthroughs for A155. For clarity I've posted them as separate messages and given them separate ratings.
I'll rate my first walkthrough at Hard 1.25 because of steps 14 and 16.
Here is my first walkthrough.
Prelims
a) R1C34 = {49/58/67}, no 1,2,3
b) R56C9 = {69/78}
c) 20(3) cage in N3 = {389/479/569/578}, no 1,2
d) 11(3) cage at R4C3 = {128/137/146/236/245}, no 9
e) 19(3) cage at R5C3 = {289/379/469/478/568}, no 1
f) R7C678 = {289/379/469/478/568}, no 1
g) 10(3) cage in N7 = {127/136/145/235}, no 8,9
h) 19(3) cage in N7 = {289/379/469/478/568}, no 1
i) R9C789 = {289/379/469/478/568}, no 1
j) 11(3) cage in N9 = {128/137/146/236/245}, no 9
k) 8(3) cage at R8C7 = {125/134}, CPE no 1 in R8C456 (also R9C789 if I hadn’t done that 19(3) cage first)
l) 12(4) cage at R2C9 = {1236/1245}, no 7,8,9
m) 12(4) cage at R5C6 = {1236/1245}, no 7,8,9
1. 45 rule on R123 2 outies R4C19 = 14 = [95/86]
1a. 12(4) cage at R2C9 = {1236/1245}
1b. 1,2 locked in R2C9 + R3C89, locked for N3
1c. R4C9 = {56} -> no 5,6 in R2C9 + R3C89
2. 45 rule on R789 2 outies R6C14 = 4 = {13}, locked for R6
2a. 12(4) cage at R5C6 = {1236/1245}
2b. 1 locked in R5C67, locked for R5
2c. 1,3 of {1236} must be in R5C67 -> no 6 in R5C67
2d. Max R6C1 = 3 -> min R7C12 = 13, no 1,2,3
3. 45 rule on N7 1 outie R6C1 = 1 innie R7C3 -> R7C3 = {13}
[Alternatively 45 rule on N89 2 outies R6C4 + R7C4 = 4 = {13}]
3a. Naked pair {13} in R6C4 + R7C3, locked for 19(5) cage
3b. 1 in N8 locked in R9C456, locked for R9
4. 45 rule on N9 1 outie R7C6 = 1 innie R8C7 + 4, no 2,3,4 in R7C6
5. 45 rule on R89 1 innie R8C4 = 1 outie R7C9 + 5, no 5,6,7,8 in R7C9, no 2,4,5 in R8C4
6. 45 rule on N89 3 innies R7C45 + R8C4 = 15 = {249/258/267/456}
6a. 8,9 of {249/258} must be in R8C4 -> no 8,9 in R7C45
[Alternatively R7C45 + R8C4 = 15 from 19(5) cage with R6C4 + R7C3 = {13} = 4]
7. 45 rule on N4 4 innies R46C1 + R45C3 = 15 = {1239/1248} (only valid combinations because R4C1 must contain one of 8,9), no 5,6,7, 1,2 locked for N4
7a. 2 locked in R45C3, locked for C3, CPE no 2 in R5C5
7b. R4C1 = {89} -> no 8,9 in R45C3
7c. Max R5C3 = 4 -> min R5C4 + R6C5 = 15, no 2,3,4,5
8. 11(3) cage at R4C3 = {128/137/146/236/245}
8a. 8 of {128} must be in R5C5 -> no 8 in R4C4
9. 45 rule on N1 3 innies R123C3 = 1 outie R4C1 + 11
9a. R4C1 = {89} -> R123C3 = 19,20, no 1
10. 45 rule on C12 1 outie R6C3 = 1 innie R9C2, no 2,3 in R9C2
10a. 2 in N7 locked in 10(3) cage = {127/235}, no 4,6
10b. Killer pair 1,3 in R7C3 and 10(3) cage, locked for N7
11. 45 rule on N7 3 innies R7C123 = 16
11a. 45 rule on R7 remaining innies R7C459 = 10 = {127/145/235} (cannot be {136} which clashes with R7C3), no 6
11b. 1,3 only in R7C9 -> R7C9 = {13}, clean-up: no 7,9 in R8C4 (step 5)
11c. Naked pair {13} in R7C39, locked for R7
[At this stage I ought to have listed the combinations for R7C123 or for the 19(3) cage in N7. See alternative walkthrough in my next message.]
12. 11(3) cage in N9 = {128/137/146/236} (cannot be {245} because R7C9 only contains 1,3), no 5
13. R7C45 + R8C4 (step 6) = {258/267/456}
13a. 45 rule on N9 3 outies R7C6 + R9C56 = 12 = {129/138/147/345} (cannot be {156/246} which clash with R7C45 + R8C4, cannot be {237} which clashes with combinations of 8(3) cage at R8C7), no 6, clean-up: no 2 in R8C7 (step 4)
14. 45 rule on N9 3 innies R7C78 + R8C7 = 15 = {249/258/456} (cannot be {159/357} because R7C678 cannot be 5{59}/7{57}, cannot be {168/267/348} which clash with 11(3) cage), no 1,3,7, clean-up: no 5,7 in R7C6 (step 4)
15. 8(3) cage at R8C7 = {125/134}
15a. 1 locked in R9C56, locked for R9
15b. R8C7 = {45} -> no 4,5 in R9C56
16. 18(3) cage in N8 = {279/378/459} (cannot be {369} which clashes with R7C6 + R8C4 (ALS block), cannot be {468/567} which clash with R7C45 + R8C4), no 6
17. R8C4 = 6 (hidden single in N8), R7C9 = 1 (step 5), R7C3 = 3, R6C4 = 1, R6C1 = 3, clean-up: no 7 in R1C3, no 5 in 10(3) cage in N7 (step 10a)
17a. R7C9 = 1 -> R8C89 (step 12) = {28/37}, no 4
17b. Killer pair 2,7 in R8C12 and R8C89, locked for R8
17c. Naked triple {127} in 10(3) cage, locked for N7, clean-up: no 7 in R6C3 (step 10)
17d. 18(3) cage in N8 (step 16) = {378/459} (cannot be {279} because 2,7 only in R9C4), no 2
17e. 7 of {378} must be in R9C4 -> no 3 in R9C4
18. R3C8 = 1 (hidden single in C8)
18a. R234C9 = {236/245}, 2 locked for C9, clean-up: no 8 in R8C8 (step 17a)
19. R6C1 = 3 -> R46C1 + R45C3 (step 7) = {1239} (only remaining combination) -> R4C1 = 9, R45C3 = [12], R4C9 = 5 (step 1), clean-up: no 3 in R23C9 (step 18a), no 9 in R9C2 (step 10)
19a. Naked pair {24} in R23C9, locked for C9 and N3
20. R5C3 = 2 -> R5C4 + R6C5 = 17 = {89}, locked for N5
21. R5C7 = 1 (hidden single in R5)
21a. 12(4) cage at R5C6 = {1236/1245}, 2 locked in R6C68, locked for R6
22. R4C3 = 1 -> R4C4 + R5C5 = 10 = [37/46/73], no 2 in R4C4, no 4,5 in R5C5
23. 30(6) cage at R4C5 = {234678} (only remaining combination), no 9, 8 locked in R4C78 + R5C8 + R6C7, locked for N6, clean-up: no 7 in R56C9
24. Naked pair {69} in R56C9, locked for C9 and N6
25. 6 of 30(6) cage at R4C5 (step 23) locked in R4C56, locked for R4 and N5, clean-up: no 4 in R4C4 (step 22)
25a. Naked pair {37} in R4C4 + R5C5, locked for N5
25b. 5 in N5 locked in R56C6, locked for C6
26. R6C1 = 3 -> R7C12 = 13 = [49/58/85], no 6 in R7C1, no 4,6 in R7C2
26a. 6 in N7 locked in R9C23, locked for R9
27. R7C678 = {469/568} (cannot be {289} which clashes with R7C12), no 2
27a. Killer pair 8,9 in R7C12 and R7C6, locked for R7
28. R7C45 = {27}(hidden pair in R7), locked for N8, clean-up: no 3,8 in 18(3) cage (step 17d)
29. R7C6 = 8 (hidden single in N8), R8C7 = 4 (step 4), R8C56 = [59], R9C4 = 4, R8C3 = 8, clean-up: no 9 in R1C3, no 5 in R1C4, no 4 in R6C3 (step 10), no 5 in R7C12 (step 26), no 2 in R8C8 (step 17a)
29a. R7C12 = [49]
30. Naked pair {37} in R8C89, locked for R8 and N9 -> R9C9 = 8, clean-up: no 5 in R9C78 (prelim i)
30a. R9C1 = 7 (hidden single in R9)
31. X-Wing for 7 in R4C4 + R5C5 and R7C45, no other 7 in C45, clean-up: no 6 in R1C3
32. R23C3 = {79} (hidden pair in C3), locked for N1 and 21(4) cage at R1C5
32a. R23C4 = {79} = 16 -> R1C5 + R2C4 = 5 = {23} (cannot be {14} because 1,4 only in R1C5), locked for N2
[Naked pair {56} in R69C3, locked for C3 -> R1C3 = 4, R1C4 = 9 …, as in step 28 of my second walkthrough, followed by naked pair {79} in R23C4 … is more direct.]
33. R3C4 = 5 (hidden single in C4)
33a. 31(5) cage at R2C6 = {35689/45679}, no 1
33b. 9 locked in R3C57, locked for R3 -> R23C3 = [97]
34. 20(3) cage in N3 = {389/578} (cannot be {569} because R1C9 only contains 3,7), no 6, 8 locked in R12C8, locked for C8 and N3
34a. R1C9 = {37} -> no 3,7 in R12C8
35. R7C8 = 6 (hidden single in C8), R7C7 = 5
36. 5 in N3 locked in 20(3) cage (step 34) = {578} -> R1C9 = 7, R12C8 = {58}, R8C89 = [73]
36a. Naked triple {369} in R123C7, locked for C7 -> R9C78 = [29]
37. 45 rule on N23 1 remaining innie R1C4 = 9, R1C3 = 4, R5C4 = 8, R6C5 = 9, R56C9 = [96], R6C3 = 5, R5C1 = 6, R9C23 = [56]
37a. R2C6 = 7 (hidden single in R2)
37b. R3C7 = 9 (hidden single in R3), clean-up: no 8 in R3C5 (step 33a)
37c. R5C6 = 5 (hidden single in R5)
38. Naked pair {46} in R3C56, locked for R3 and N2
39. 5 in N1 locked in R12C1 -> 13(3) cage = {256} (only remaining combination) -> R1C2 = 6, R12C1 = {25}, locked for C1 and N1
and the rest is naked singles